• Post Vacancy
  • Register
  • Jobs

The Devil You Know Might Be the One That Lets You Go

  • Posted 18 Nov 2026
  • Richard Holmes
  • Article

Staying put feels safe

A few weeks ago I wrote about why good finance people aren't moving. The response told me it struck a nerve. Plenty of hiring managers said they were seeing it in their own teams, and plenty of candidates said it described exactly how they felt.

The short version: stability has become what people want most. When the market feels uncertain, staying with an employer you know feels like the sensible choice, even if the role stopped growing you a while ago.

I still believe that. What I didn't say, and probably should have, is that the safety people are staying for often isn't there at all.

Nobody is as safe as they think

This year I've watched good, loyal finance people get made redundant. These weren't underperformers. They were people who had been in the business for years, knew where every number came from, and had turned down other opportunities because they felt valued where they were.

In most cases it had nothing to do with them. A new owner came in, a restructure was drawn up, or a cost target had to be met, and their role became a line on a spreadsheet. Loyalty and tenure rarely come up in that conversation.

The hard part is that many of them stayed for security. They'd been approached about roles that would have moved their careers forward, and they said no because leaving felt like the bigger risk. As it turned out, staying was the risk.

settling isn't something any of us canSo when someone tells me they're waiting for things to settle before they think about their next move, I get it. I also know that things settling isn't something any of us get to control.

The cost of doing nothing

It isn't only candidates who are frozen at the moment. A lot of businesses are too.

I'm seeing roles approved for months without anyone pressing the button, and shortlists that keep growing because someone wants to see a few more people before deciding. On the other side, I'm seeing good candidates sit on offers for weeks while they wait to feel better about the market. Everyone is waiting for certainty, and I don't think it's coming any time soon.

Doing nothing feels neutral, but it has a real cost. The team covering a vacant role gets tired, month end gets harder and projects quietly slip. Your best person, who has been doing two jobs for six months, starts taking calls from recruiters. The role you were nervous about filling ends up costing far more than the hire ever would have.

The same thing happens to candidates. Someone who sits on a good opportunity for too long usually ends up with no opportunity at all, and the job they stayed in for security is no more secure than it was before.

What hiring managers can do differently?

Nobody needs to take reckless risks right now. What helps is making it easier for good people to say yes to you, and easier for your own business to make the call.

  • Be honest about stability, because candidates will ask how the business is performing and why the role exists, and the ones who get straight answers are the ones who move.
  • Agree what good looks like before you start interviewing, so you recognise the right person when you meet them instead of waiting to see who else turns up.
  • Set a decision date at the start of the process and hold yourself to it.
  • Keep the process to the stages you genuinely need, because every extra week gives a cautious candidate another reason to stay where they are.
  • Treat a strong internal person who is covering the vacancy as a retention risk rather than a solution.
  • Make your offer about more than salary, since a counteroffer will often match the money but rarely matches the career.

A word for you, not your team

Most people reading this hire finance talent, but you're employees as well, and the same rules apply to you.

Looking after yourself means keeping your network warm when you're happy, taking the call when someone reaches out even if the answer is no, and having a rough idea of your next move before you need one. None of that is disloyal. Nobody else is going to manage your career for you, no matter how much they value you today.

The worst time to start thinking about your next role is the day someone else has already made a decision about your current one.

Better the devil you know is still how a lot of people think, and I understand why. The trouble is that the devil you know can change its mind about you overnight.

For hiring managers, that's an opportunity. If you can show real stability, move with some confidence and give people a clear reason to make the jump, you'll find good people are more willing to move than the market suggests.

For the rest of us, it's a reminder that real security comes from having options, not from the business you happen to work for.

Richard Holmes is Co-Founder and Director of HPR Consulting, a specialist senior finance recruitment firm placing CFOs, Finance Directors, Commercial & FP&A leaders into ASX listed, private equity backed and fast growing businesses across Australia.

Back Next Post