Back in March, I wrote that the senior finance market was competitive but not broken. Four months on, that assessment still holds. What has changed is how the market is sorting winners from everyone else.
The headline numbers tell a stable story. Unemployment eased to 4.4% in May, down from a four-year high of 4.5% in April, and employment growth has been solid. On paper, that looks like a healthy market.
But paper numbers were never the real story for senior finance professionals, and they matter even less now.
The story this quarter is the widening gap between two job searches. There is the public one, where hundreds of applicants chase a handful of advertised roles. And there is the one most people never see, where roles get filled before a job ad is ever written.
Let me walk you through what is actually happening, what the data shows, and what it means if you are hiring or looking for your next move.
The labour market in brief
Employment conditions have been choppy but resilient. After unemployment spiked to 4.5% in April, the highest level in more than four years, it eased back to 4.4% in May, with employment rising by over 40,000 people in the strongest monthly gain since December.
That volatility matters more than the headline rate. It tells us businesses are still hiring, but with more caution and less certainty than this time last year. For senior finance roles specifically, that caution shows up as longer processes, more stakeholders involved in the final decision, and a sharper focus on candidates who can prove commercial impact rather than just technical competence.
The part of the market you cannot see
This is the conversation I keep having with senior finance professionals right now.
"I am applying to roles that match my background perfectly and hearing nothing back."
This is not new, but it is more pronounced than it was in March. The reason is structural, not personal.
Industry data consistently shows that a significant majority of professional and executive roles are filled without ever being advertised publicly. At senior levels, including CFO, Finance Director, and Group Financial Controller, that figure is higher still. Boards and hiring committees often run confidential searches before a role is ever posted, working through retained recruiters, peer referrals, and direct outreach to people they already trust.
Think about what that means in practice. For every senior finance opening in the market right now, a meaningful share will be filled through someone's network, a recruiter's relationship database, or a direct conversation, well before a job board ever sees it.
This is why two equally qualified candidates can have completely different experiences. One spends months submitting applications into job boards and wonders what is wrong with their resume. The other has a single conversation with the right person and is shortlisted for a role that was never advertised.
Nothing is wrong with the first candidate's resume. They are simply playing in the visible 20% of the market while the real opportunity sits in the other 80%.
Why this matters more now than it did in March
A few things have shifted since the start of the year that make direct access more important, not less.
Put simply, the market has not slowed down. It has gone quieter. The activity has moved from job boards into networks, recruiter relationships, and direct conversations.
What this means if you are looking for your next role
If your entire strategy is built around applying for advertised vacancies, you are competing for a shrinking, increasingly crowded slice of the market.
The professionals landing strong roles right now share a few habits.
None of this is about working harder. It is about putting your effort where the actual opportunities are, rather than where they are easiest to see.
What this means if you are hiring
For businesses hiring senior finance talent, the same dynamic cuts both ways.
If your search strategy starts and ends with a job ad, you are only reaching the candidates who happen to be actively looking and scrolling job boards on the right day. The strongest candidates, the ones already excelling in their current role, are rarely browsing job ads. They are reachable, but only through a direct approach.
Businesses getting this right are doing a few things consistently.
The businesses that treat senior hiring as a relationship business, not a transaction, are the ones consistently landing the candidates everyone else never gets in front of.
The outlook through to the end of 2026
The honest read remains close to where it was in March, with a sharper edge to it now.
The roles being filled right now are not always the ones you can see.
That is not a reason to give up on a structured search. It is a reason to change where you focus your energy. The candidates winning in this market are not applying more. They are connecting more, and connecting with the right people.
The businesses hiring best are not posting more job ads. They are building stronger relationships with the people who already know where the talent is.
If your search, on either side of the table, still lives entirely on job boards, you are only seeing part of the market. The other part is built on conversations, not applications.
HPR Consulting - Your Partner in Senior Finance Recruitment
With more than two decades of experience placing senior finance professionals across Australia, HPR Consulting partners with businesses and finance leaders to navigate complex hiring decisions.